Cuckoos of the World by Johannes Erritzøe et al.
The introductory section gives a fascinating overview of this varied family, from systematics to conservation. The colour plates are magnificent, painted by four different artists but sitting side by side without any clash in styles. A single plate includes multiple illustrations for up to six species but it's largely clear which illustrations belong to which species, and the space is generally well used without feeling cluttered. The maps are clear and easy to understand, so long as you know which part of the world you're looking at — a map containing just an island group can be hard to put into context until you've read the text. Dotted lines denote subspecies limits, an extremely useful addition missing from a surprising number of other publications. The photography is stunning and it's an impressive statistic that close to 140 of the species featured in the book have at least one in-the-field photograph associated with the them; my personal favourites are the dazzling African Emerald Cuckoo featured in the introduction and the pastel-shaded Grey-capped Cuckoo on page 307.Yellow-billed Cuckoo raise their own young, occasionally with the added assistance of a 'helper male'; some females may lay their eggs in the nest of an unrelated pair of Yellow-billed Cuckoos; and some females may lay their eggs in the nest of an unrelated species such as Black-billed Cuckoo, American Robin or even Mourning Dove. If that list seems varied, the list of species parasitized by Common Cuckoos is quite mind-blowing: Black-eared Wheatear, Moussier's Redstart, Tristram's Warbler, Isabelline Shrike, Black-headed Bunting, Scrub Warbler, to name a few of the more unusual. The species text accounts really are a fascinating read.
However, as interesting as these accounts are, the reading can sometimes be hard going. The writing occasionally contradicts itself, while sentences lack flow and occasionally give the impression that Yoda might have had an input into their syntax. Confusing sometimes this can get. Illustrating the point nicely, from the Long-tailed Koel distribution section: "Makes non-stop flights of up to 3,000km (Robertson 1985) but vagrants to Palau I. cover nearly 6,000km over open sea (Dorst 1962). Once Queensland (Barrett et al. 2003), an earlier record, and two NT, Australia, considered unconfirmed (Higgins 1999)."
I have further reservations with this book, though perhaps less critical to the average user. "Great," I thought when the publication first arrived on my desk, "I'll be able to look up the latest moult information and ageing criteria for Common Cuckoo" — such are the priorities in my life. I was disappointed to find that the moult section for the species consisted of one sentence about timing of body moult. And, since the most widespread method for ageing Common Cuckoos relies on the assessment of retained secondaries (not mentioned under 'Moult'), it's perhaps not surprising that the only age classes covered under 'Description' are juvenile and 'adult'. Perhaps I'm being pedantic. After all, ageing Common Cuckoos is subtle at best; so how about a more obvious species, the Great Spotted Cuckoo? The species often shows a distinctive first-summer plumage — so much so that it's even illustrated in some general-purpose field guides. Sadly in Cuckoos there is not even so much as a hint that there might be a recognisable plumage between juvenile and 'full adult'.
Ultimately, this book does shine brightly in many areas. If you can overlook the absence of some of the more technical aspects of morphology — and the slightly hefty price tag — then the artwork, the photographs, the illuminating text on behaviour and nesting, and the overview of identification of all the world's cuckoos are likely to make this book an attractive addition to the Helm Identification Guides family.
Hardcover, 544 pages
Christopher Helm, RRP: £60.00