Why males outnumber females in birds?

Singing male Willow Warblers do not necessarily indicate breeding pairs, as females often desert areas with a low density. Photo: Andreas Eichler (commons.wikimedia.org).
Singing male Willow Warblers do not necessarily indicate breeding pairs, as females often desert areas with a low density. Photo: Andreas Eichler (commons.wikimedia.org).
Female birds leave sparsely populated breeding sites behind deserting smaller populations of lonely males, according to new research from the University of East Anglia (UEA), Norwich.

Research published in the Journal of Animal Ecology shows for the first time the causes of skewed sex ratios among small and declining bird populations. The findings reveal how female birds are thought to choose busier breeding locations – where habitat is often better, males are more abundant, and the ratio of males to females is more equal.

Lead researcher Professor Jenny Gill from UEA’s School of Biological Sciences, said: “Many migratory bird populations are declining and very small local populations are becoming more common.

“If females prefer places where males are more abundant, small populations are likely to decline even faster. However, the unpaired males will continue singing throughout the breeding season in a bid to find a mate, and so we may be underestimating declines in these small populations. We wanted to find out whether this was happening.”

The research team used British Trust for Ornithology (BTO) ringing data to explore the extent, causes and consequences of varying sex ratios in breeding populations of Willow Warblers across Britain. Around 8,000 birds were surveyed from 34 sites over 18 years.

Professor Gill said: “Willow Warblers are migratory birds that breed in Europe and spend their winters in sub-Saharan Africa. They have a typical lifespan of two years. They are caught and recorded in large numbers at survey sites throughout the UK.

“Their population trends vary greatly across Britain, with small and declining populations in the south-east and larger more stable populations in the north-west. This spatial variation gave us the opportunity to explore the links between population size and sex ratios, as well as the associated causes and consequences of skewed sex ratios over a large area.”

Lead author Dr Catriona Morrison said: “We found that, back in 1994, the male-female ratio was pretty much 50:50. But over time the males started to outnumber the females, and by 2012 males comprised around 60 per cent of the population.

“But we also found that sites with smaller numbers of birds had a greater proportion of males. So, for example, in sites in the North-West where Willow Warblers are very abundant, the male-female ratio was still close to 50:50, but a high proportion of males is common on sites in the South-East where the birds are less abundant. Unfortunately, the frequency of populations with a larger ratio of males is increasing, probably because small populations are becoming more common through habitat fragmentation.

“In male-biased sites we would expect to find fewer juveniles, and indeed we found that the proportion of juveniles was highest when sex ratios were closest to equality, but declined as ratios became more skewed. We also found that females tended to have lower survival rates than males across the board, but that this alone is not enough to drive the skewed sex ratios.

“What this all shows us is that females are probably joining sites with large populations – perhaps because they are attracted to the males or because there is a larger amount of suitable habitat. Having skewed sex ratios is problematic because it means individuals will not be able to find a mate and breed. This could potentially drive faster declines in small populations.”
The research team recommend that conservation efforts should focus on maintaining and enhancing sites capable of supporting large populations that are likely to have more equal sex ratios.

Morrison, C, Robinson, R, Clark, J A, and Gill, J. 2016. Causes and consequences of spatial variation in sex ratios in a declining bird species. Journal of Animal Ecology 85: 1298-1306.