Rarity finders Red-winged Blackbird on North Ronaldsay


After seemingly weeks of endless strong westerly, north-westerly or northerly winds bringing snow and hail most days, we were overjoyed when the wind finally swung round to the east. After a day of slack weather, however, it picked up again, as a cold force 6-7 blew through, although still from the right direction.

I had a pretty decent morning's birding while carrying out the northern census route, with some wildfowl moving offshore, some pristine full summer-plumaged Snow Buntings, a Black Redstart and a Merlin which caught a Starling right in front of me. I was walking back past the house at Garso with my mind half on what we had to do in the afternoon to get the ‘obs’ ready for a tour group, when a strange little chup call spun me round in time to see a Starling-sized bird land on top of some gas bottles outside the house.

I could just see its head, which showed a broad supercillium, yellowish throat, streaked chest and pointed bill. My brain stuttered for a second as I said to myself: “Redwing ... no, yes ... No!”

Red-winged Blackbird
Red-winged Blackbird, North Ronaldsay, Orkney, 29 April 2017 (Photo: Simon Davies)

I took a few steps to my right and could see the whole bird about 15 m away. It was indeed a chunky passerine with dark crown, broad, flaring supercillium, yellowish at the front, a dark eyestripe and a yellowish chin patch with dark, bold streaks down the front (slightly thinner in the centre) – the thought ‘calidus Peregrine-style’ bizarrely popped into my head! The two white wing-bars were also obvious, as were the chestnut scapulars and mantle. It was a stunning bird, despite being brown and streaky.

I asked myself: ‘What the hell is that?’ and took a look closer at it with my eyes and my camera lens, while trying to sort it out in my head. My jumbled thoughts ran somewhere along the lines of: “Look at that bill, looks like an American oriole ... but it’s not one of those ... but it must be American ... what else is like that? Some kind of blackbird/grackle? No, grackles are bigger ... must be a blackbird ... which ones have I seen? Red-winged in Texas, no others ... but there are others; females are dark and streaky like that. God! It might actually be a Red-winged Blackbird ...”

After a few minutes, it flew up with a really distinctive, floppy flight and showed a fan-shaped tail, which also flopped around as it flew up onto the wires, where it perched for a minute or so before dropping down into a nearby iris bed. I found some shelter from the wind and began to phone the obs volunteers, who were working other parts of the island, relaying a message reading something like: “Odd bird at Garso – it’s American and mega. Not 100 per cent sure what it is but best guess is Red-winged Blackbird.” My colleague Larissa helpfully asked: “Is it black with red wings?” “No,” I replied.

I had now lost the bird and failed to re-find it before Sam, Larissa and Harris arrived. After what seemed like ages but was probably only 15 minutes, it flew up from the irises to make a beeline straight back to the gas bottles, where we all had excellent views. Larissa, being Canadian, was probably best placed to help with the ID and tentatively agreed with my first thoughts, as did Pete Donnelly, who arrived shortly afterwards. I then tweeted back of the camera pictures out into the world, and that was that!

Kevin Woodbridge and Alison Duncan were off island for the day (as they always are when rare birds are found!), but they arrived back on the last scheduled flight of the day and soon had great views of the bird as it followed the pattern of heading to and from the gas bottles. The phones were red hot for the rest of the evening, with people booking in, making plans and congratulating us, while we sat back and relaxed with a beer or two.

The first planes arrived at 9.30 am the next morning, and with the bird sticking to its routine everyone connected and had great views. There were some adverse internet comments regarding the organised flushes, which occurred a minimum of 1.5 hours apart (though usually much longer than that) and were undertaken by just one obs staff member at a time. This strategy was designed to minimise disturbance to the bird, the habitat and the privately owned land it was frequenting, with the alternative being every plane load of folks fanning out and trampling through the area, disturbing breeding birds – and of course the blackbird itself.

As I write, the bird is still present, with everyone who has come having a great and successful time of it. The phones are still ringing with more bookings, newspapers and radio stations all wanting a piece on this potential first for Britain and the Western Palearctic.

Red-winged Blackbird

Red-winged Blackbird, North Ronaldsay, Orkney, 29 April 2017 (Photo: Simon Davies)

Related pages

Red-winged Blackbird Red-winged Blackbird
Orkney Orkney

Related articles

Rarity finders Spectacled Warbler at Portland Rarity finders Spectacled Warbler at Portland
Andy Davidson recounts a memorable afternoon at Portland Bill where, among a fall of migrants, he found Britain's ninth Spectacled Warbler. read on read on
Rarity finders Black-browed Albatross at Bempton Cliffs Rarity finders Black-browed Albatross at Bempton Cliffs
Twelve-year-old Joe Fryer demonstrated great nous to find and identify a Black-browed Albatross at the famous Yorkshire reserve of Bempton Cliffs. read on read on
Rarity finders Oriental Turtle Dove in West Yorkshire Rarity finders Oriental Turtle Dove in West Yorkshire
A couple of photos passed along by a work colleague alerted Duncan Watson to the presence of a mega eastern dove in West Yorkshire, but the bird now seems to be long gone. read on read on
Rarity finders American Herring Gull in Suffolk Rarity finders American Herring Gull in Suffolk
Pete Wilson's diversion via a local Suffolk pig farm paid off when a rare Nearctic gull emerged from the throng. read on read on
Rarity finders Hermit Thrush on Noss Rarity finders Hermit Thrush on Noss
Craig Nisbet, Reserve Warden at Scottish Natural Heritage, clapped his hands in a Shetland island geo and flushed a mega Yank thrush, which fortunately stayed for others to see. read on read on

The information in this article was believed correct at the time of writing. BirdGuides accepts no responsibility for errors, or for any consequences of acting on information in the article. The opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and are not necessarily shared by BirdGuides Ltd.

hide section Reader comments (0)

No comments so far.

Back to top Back to top

Latest edition Latest edition
Search articles Search articles
All articles All articles
Popular articles Popular articles
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Terms of Sale | Cookie Policy | About us | Advertise | Contact us
BirdGuides, Warners Group Publications PLC, The Chocolate Factory, 5 Clarendon Road, London N22 6XJ
© 2017 BirdGuides and Warners Group Publications plc. All Rights Reserved. Company Registered in England no. 2572212 | VAT registration No. GB 638 3492 15
Sales: or tel. 0800 919391 · International Sales: +44 (0)1778 391180 · Office: or tel. 020 8826 0934

Fatbirder's Top 1000 Birding Websites