Review Facing Extinction


Rhetoric is easy, rhetoric abounds and rhetoric is a waste without action. It's clichéd beyond triteness, but actions do speak louder than words. Take Hawaii as an example. The 50th American state is a top priority conservation concern; yet it received only 4% of federal spending on threatened species between 1996 and 2004. It's grimly unsurprising then that 70% of Hawaii's native birds are extinct. It seems every week there's a different press release splashed across the news about the next species to pass from this world. So it's in this context that we receive the latest of the current crop of books on extinction. Facing Extinction, jointly authored by four conservationists, features just 20 species, dealt with as case studies and divided into four broad topics related to the variables affecting rarity. It is at the very least proof of action, from the frontlines of the global fight against extinction.

Opening with a discussion of rarity, from psychological experiments on the attraction of rarity, to the nature of rarity and the rarity of nature, the book strikes an initial upbeat note: of the 10,000 or so birds, fewer than 2% qualify as Critically Endangered and the number of Data Deficient species is also relatively low. It successfully hurdles the potential stumbling blocks of explaining tricky theories (anthropogenic Allee, etc.) with startling ease — clarity characterises the writing in this book — before it settles into the species case studies. The Sociable Lapwing starts, setting out the basic template: a decline, a frantic search for a cause and then the conservation efforts and their effects. The 20 species it features are spread globally and in varying states of peril, from the Stephen's Island Wren (extinct for c.100 years) and current cause célèbres such as the Spoon-billed Sandpiper (200 pairs maximum) to the downright obscure Alagoas Curassow. All species illustrate different issues, processes or effects. Despite being grouped into four broad themes, there is very little overlap between chapters, hence it stays fresh and distinct and illustrates the breadth of the issues at hand.

The topic is nothing original. Recent years have seen a glut of books on extinction, but Facing Extinction succeeds in not being a dry rehashing of scientific papers or a self-righteous exercise in guilt-tripping. Instead, it is the quality of its stories: some horrifying and some hopeful, but all are compelling. A book like this cannot be much more than a marker in time, but with population statistics as recent as 2010 (where available) it is as up to date as it possibly can be.

Sociable Lapwing
Sociable Lapwing, Qatar (Photo: anon)

Science and narrative are confidently interwoven and the result is both edifying and accessible; this is not death by statistics, bar charts and formulae but is instead delivered in accessible language. In tone and style, it's as middle-of-the-road as possible for a popular academic text, but this shouldn't be off-putting. Impartial delivery is the strength of academic writing, and so it avoids slipping into an exaggerated, preachy rhetoric; the paragraphs touching on global warming are apocalyptic enough without it. The dearth of literary style does emphasise its occasional flourishes, for example, the simile about Kazakhstan's Black Larks — 'coal-black males dot the snowy wastes like the eyes of legions of melted snowmen' — was a surprise in the Sociable Lapwing chapter. Sporadically they lift the prose, but what it might lack in literary merit and flow, it regains in a startling clarity. Terminology and theories are dealt with clearly, concisely and with the confidence that comes with expertise, which makes reading this book such a painless exercise. It is truly remarkable how easy to read and yet thorough this book is; all birders should be able to read it, enjoy it and learn from it. Similarities in style bridge the seams between the writers; it doesn't read or feel like the product of a cross-conservation-organisation committee.

Unexpectedly, Facing Extinction features the very best and worst of humanity. Humans accidently introduced the House Mouse to Gough, which are now consuming three tonnes of native plants, insects and birds every day, including Tristan Albatross chicks, 300 times bigger than their killers. More infuriatingly, humans trapped the Spix's Macaw into its status of 'Extinct In The Wild'; accidently poisoned the Asian Gyps vultures into vertiginous declines of over 99%; made firewood for tourists from the Peruvian Polylepis forests, further fragmenting the Royal Cinclodes's range; and played politics with the Po'ouli. Broadly, humanity has the blood of the global avifauna on its hands. Yet all this contrasts with people like Pedro Nardelli, an aviculturist who, for over 10 years, held the entire population of the Alagoas Curassow in his private collection, while the Brazilian government's conservation authority was "crippled by bureaucracy and lack of financial support"; or Philip Round's tireless efforts in Thailand to rediscover the glorious Gurney's Pitta. For all its impressive research and scholarly merit, it is these stories that elevate the book from a heavyweight scientific tome into a compulsive read.

Gurney's Pitta
Gurney's Pitta, Thailand (Photo: Ian Fulton)

At 312 pages (including 24 pages of references) and £45, it is both small and expensive. Price pitches it at the hardback heavyweights — the New Naturalists and the family monographs — but as a book it couldn't be more different. The nature of the subject matter makes it more important, but it lacks the practical application to field birding in Britain that makes other similarly priced books essential. However, for your money, the production quality is fantastic throughout the book, the editing is faultless and the frequently used photographs, sketched vignettes (by Jan Wilczur) and maps are all of a good quality. Appropriately all the royalties from the book will be donated to BirdLife's Preventing Extinction programme.

It's hard to pick out one element of this book that stands superior to the rest. Pitched perfectly for birders, not patronisingly dumbed down or needing a degree for comprehension, it's a uniquely easy and edifying read, which combined with the importance of its subject matter makes it an indispensible reference.

Facing Extinction Paul Donald, Nigel Collar, Stuart Marsden and Deborah Painby is published by Poyser, 2010.
Hardcover. 312 pages.
RRP £45.00. ISBN: 978-0-7136-7021-9

Related articles

Review Birdwatcher's Diary app Review Birdwatcher's Diary app
Is there a better way to record sightings in the field than the age-old combination of pen and notebook? This popular app from Stevens Creek Software aims to convince you that there is. read on read on
Review Tom Lock Series 2 8×42 and 10×42 binoculars Review Tom Lock Series 2 8×42 and 10×42 binoculars
Mike Alibone reviews Opticalia's latest binocular offering and finds that the new incarnation of the Tom Lock range offers seriously good value for money. read on read on
Review Petrels Night and Day by Magnus Robb, Killian Mullarney and The Sound Approach (iBook edition) Review Petrels Night and Day by Magnus Robb, Killian Mullarney and The Sound Approach (iBook edition)
An incredible journey: Alan Tilmouth reviews the latest digital offering from the Sound Approach team. read on read on
Review Challenge Series: Winter by Martin Garner Review Challenge Series: Winter by Martin Garner
Josh Jones examines the second instalment in Martin Garner's seasonal bird identification series. read on read on
Review A Birdwatchers' Guide to Portugal, the Azores and Madeira Archipelagos Review A Birdwatchers' Guide to Portugal, the Azores and Madeira Archipelagos
Dominic Mitchell reviews the significantly expanded update to a volume first published in 1997. read on read on

The information in this article was believed correct at the time of writing. BirdGuides accepts no responsibility for errors, or for any consequences of acting on information in the article. The opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and are not necessarily shared by BirdGuides Ltd.

hide section Reader comments (0)

No comments so far.

Back to top Back to top

Latest edition Latest edition
Search articles Search articles
All articles All articles
Popular articles Popular articles
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Terms of Sale | Cookie Policy | About us | Advertise | Contact us
BirdGuides, Warners Group Publications PLC, The Chocolate Factory, 5 Clarendon Road, London N22 6XJ
© 2015 BirdGuides and Warners Group Publications plc. All Rights Reserved. Company Registered in England no. 2572212 | VAT registration No. GB 638 3492 15
Sales: or tel. 0800 919391 · International Sales: +44 (0)1778 391180 · Office: or tel. 020 8826 0934

Fatbirder's Top 1000 Birding Websites