Home
 
 

Dead lamb laced with poison kills Irish bred Golden Eagle chick

 
 
This page contains 16 reader comments. Click here to view (latest Mon 15/03/10 23:38).

A young Irish Golden Eagle has been found poisoned on the Sligo/Leitrim border at Truskmore Mountain. The 10-month-old eagle chick was born and reared in a Donegal eyrie in 2009. The bird had spent the last four months wandering the beautiful mountains above Glencar Waterfall, Lough Gill and Gleniff.


The dead Irish bred Golden Eagle, Conall, lying on Truskmore Mountain overlooking Sligo Bay and Sligo Town (Photo: Golden Eagle Trust)

The bird was tracked and found using a Global Positioning System satellite transmitter fitted on its back. The corpse, recovered on the 18th February 2010, was just inside the County Leitrim border. A post mortem carried out by the Regional Veterinary Laboratory in Rathcormack, Sligo revealed that the young male was in excellent condition prior to its death. Toxicology analysis, carried out at the Ashtown Food Research Centre, Dublin, prove that the eagle was poisoned by Nitroxynil poured over the fleece of a dead newborn or aborted lamb. Gardaí in Sligo Town have begun their investigation.

This male eagle was named Conall, after "Tír Conall" — the Irish name for Donegal. Local people and children in Donegal, Sligo and Leitrim had been watching and following its regular movements on the project website.


(Map: Golden Eagle Trust)

Prior to the 2009 lambing season another satellite-tagged Golden Eagle was found poisoned with Paraquat on 19th February 2009 in West Donegal. The loss of up to 10% of Irish Golden Eagle population within a year suggests that the Golden Eagle Project could fail, unless the unlawful use of toxins by a small percentage of farmers ceases. In total, nine White-tailed Eagles, Golden Eagles and Red Kites have been confirmed poisoned in Ireland over the last two and a half years. Recent monitoring by the Golden Eagle Trust proves that poisons, such as Alphachloralose, Carbofuran, Paraquat and Nitroxynil, have been used illegally in Munster, Ulster, Leinster and now Connaught.

The Golden Eagle Trust believes that over 95% of landowners across Ireland do not use poison. It is also clear from the 11,000 comments on the Golden Eagle Trust's anti-poisoning petition (see www.goldeneagle.ie), that the illegal use of poisons is condemned across both rural and urban Ireland. The Golden Eagle Trust lodged a formal complaint with the European Union in late 2009 concerning the failure of the Irish Government to implement legislation protecting Ireland's rare scavenging birds of prey.

Sadly much good work in educating farmers has been undone by the Irish Farmers Journal. A feature advised sheep farmers that "alphachloralose...is mixed with mincemeat and fat and placed alongside a fresh stillborn lamb or even a fresh afterbirth." This appalling advice on the reckless use of poison is indicative of a disregard for regulations within a small sector of the agricultural community and more crucially within the main weekly voice of Irish farming.

Lorcán O'Toole from the Golden Eagle Trust said: "This issue is about the illegal use of poison within Irish farming. We believe the few hundred farmers using poison illegally are at variance with the huge environmental advances Irish farming has undergone over the last ten years. We have always fully acknowledged the support and co-operation of the sheep farming community in the Northwest and continue to do so. But unfortunately the poisoning of this Golden Eagle undermines the image of Irish food and weakens the potential for local tourism and damages the fragile rural economy in the Northwest, we believe. Increasingly, farmers in Ireland will look for support from the ordinary Irish consumer to support their efforts for more sustainable prices for farm produce and in maintaining the crucial farming presence in rural Ireland after pending reforms to the EU's Common Agricultural Policy. Farmers need to question whether the actions of a tiny minority could undermine that consumer support."

John Cromie of BirdWatch Ireland commented: "News of the loss to indiscriminate and illegal poisoning of one of the first native-bred Golden Eagle's has been heartbreaking, both for the reintroduction project team and for the highly supportive local community in County Donegal. All the more depressing is the fact that this young eagle was found to be in excellent condition, having survived a particularly harsh first winter. One can only hope that the public anger being expressed over this sad event will ensure that the barbaric practice, by a tiny minority of farmers, of leaving out meat-based poisons, is finally eliminated in Ireland. "

Nonetheless, with up to half-a-dozen Golden Eagle territories now well established in the northwest, there is still grounds for optimism about the long-term success of this pioneering reintroduction project.

Related pages

Golden Eagle Golden Eagle
Donegal Donegal


The information in this article was believed correct at the time of writing. BirdGuides Ltd accepts no responsibility for errors, or for any consequences of acting on information in the article. The opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and are not necessarily shared by BirdGuides Ltd.

hide section Reader comments (16)

#1
How sickening,perhaps when we are in our supermarkets we should think carefully about buying Irish meat and dairy produce!
   andrew griffin, 04/03/10 22:34Report inappropriate post Report 
#2
What a pity some of the farmers are still living in a 'time warp'---forget Ireland and release birds maybe in Wales.
   Richard berry, 05/03/10 08:40Report inappropriate post Report 
#3
Complete and utter ignorance. Are these people just completely thick or are they above the law? agreed - dont buy Irish. Wales or Cumbria - both would make more sense.
   Daniel C Martin, 05/03/10 17:56Report inappropriate post Report 
#4
It beggars beleif how some irresponsible and obviously ignorant farmers can do this to such a magnificent and quite innocent bird that is just trying to survive.It is not as if there are hundreds of the birds taking dozens of lambs etc and really is totally unnecessary. DONT BUY IRISH UNTIL IT STOPS.
   Andy Thompson, 05/03/10 19:06Report inappropriate post Report 
#5
What a sickening incident - i wonder how all those schoolkids must feel having following this magnificent birds progress - hopefully his loss will not be in vain and will only serve to put a nail in the coffin to the attiitude of a generation of farmers whose indiscrimate attitude belongs to a bygone age and will hopefully die with them - i dont agree with collective punishment for the majority of farmers that are law-abiding and serve as guardians of the countryside over there i dont recall a boycott of Irish beef during the troubles....................
   Laurie Allan, 06/03/10 07:57Report inappropriate post Report 
#6
My knowledge of Irish law is extremely slim, but could a case not be made against the Irish Farmers Journal for incitement to commit an offence? I know the wording of the quote is phrased in such a way as to make it a report rather than a recipe, but...
   Chris Fairchild, 06/03/10 08:04Report inappropriate post Report 
#7
Unfortunately I don't think the problem is restricted to Eire. My aunt had two dogs poisoned, one fatally, when they ate from the carcass of a dead lamb they found in North Wales, so it seems Welsh farmers may be just as bad.
   Elizabeth Watts, 06/03/10 09:01Report inappropriate post Report 
#8
I feel that you can legislate all you like whether it is hands-free whilst driving or lacing of sheep carcasses with poison - it then has to be enforced - it is peoples attitudes that have to change you only have to look at the previous article with regard to the MaltaSlaughter - it might be interesting if you could pin down the exact carcass and where it was placed and on whose land and then possibly take it from there but unless it is the RSPB pursuing the case then the Police are unlikely to take it further particularly if it takes them through their lunch-break ! I mean, you could'nt pin down an incident, a location and a person associated ie the shooting of the Harrier(s) on the Sandringham estate but what came of it - bugger all - random persecution is almost impossible to stop unfortunately.....
   Laurie Allan, 06/03/10 12:51Report inappropriate post Report 
#9
As you are paying a large sum of your tax for these farmers and shooting estates to carry on their work would it not be better that when Environmental Stewardship agreements are written that any removal of birds of prey from on/or adjacent land would result in payments suspended and courts could claw back previous money given to these people.
   john miles, 07/03/10 10:53Report inappropriate post Report 
#10
MASSIVE FINES, JAIL TERMS AND ACTIVE PURSUIT OF PERPETRATORS. ALSO A SHOOT ON SIGHT POLICY WOULD BE GOOD.
   LAURENCE., 11/03/10 20:23Report inappropriate post Report 
#11
Not sure if the Irish Farm Produce boycott is a very good idea...you are talking about people with a long history of defying outside pressure...and you want the good guys to do well and influence their neighbours....that was also the advice from BirdLife Malta, when asked about tourist bans over there. The last thing we need to project is a "holier than thou" attitude from across the water...eagles and other "protected" predators are still being illegally slaughtered in Scotland , England and Wales every year due to greedy, ignorant , prejudiced gamekeepers and occasional farmer/crofter. Whats happening in Ireland does affect us here, just as what happens over here will be used in Ireland...we need to clear up this mess wherever it happens...my heart goes out to Lorcan who has a lifelong battle on his hands.
   MR T D DICK, 12/03/10 11:29Report inappropriate post Report 
#12
My suggestion is that we need some people in power with a spine and some backbone! They should then hunt down these sorry excuses for human beings who are using said poisons, then they should force feed these scum the exact poisons they have been using until they die........ Regardless of whatever country they happen to come from, I generally find scum are scum whether they come from England, Wales, Scotland, North or South Ireland. Justice unfortunately is rarely dished up to this type of...more more
   Mark, 12/03/10 14:00Report inappropriate post Report 
#13
Can we keep the discussion sensible and on-topic please?
   Dave Dunford (admin), 12/03/10 14:25Report inappropriate post Report 
#14
#12....I may not agree with Mark...but hes definitely still fully on the topic!...unless you think that just reading about unpleasant real situations like this is enough? What would you suggest to stop the killing?
   MR T D DICK, 12/03/10 15:59Report inappropriate post Report 
#15
I was appalled to read of the Golden Eagle killed by poisoning, but even more so by the news of the article in the Irish farming magazine. Surly this article is sufficient to have the magazine closed down and the resonsible people (writer, editor, publisher, owners ?) jailed. If they really support conservation, the Irish authorities must prosecute the magazine that published this article. Excuses about its being a 'warning' just don' t . the irish government need to see justice done. Otherwise the only justifiable fate for them and the perpetrators is tha of the Eagle
   Dave C, 13/03/10 20:43Report inappropriate post Report 
#16
bicker away lads,but the monied classes hold sway over government policies.polititians have "scrota",but will only use them little roundy things when it suits!!!
   optionalruss king, 15/03/10 23:38Report inappropriate post Report 

Back to top Back to top

Latest edition Latest edition
Search articles Search articles
All articles All articles
Popular articles Popular articles

 
   
 
© BirdGuides Ltd 2010 · BirdGuides Ltd, PO Box 4104, Sheffield S25 9BS
Sales: or tel. 0800 919391 · International Sales: +44 (0)1536 273532 · Office: or tel. 01909 560992